
Choosing the perfect audition song can feel like navigating a maze—especially if you want to stand out with something fresh and unique. While many performers default to popular, overused songs, you can make a lasting impression by showcasing your talent with a lesser-known gem. Here are ten underrated songs that are perfect for contemporary musical theater auditions. Each selection highlights vocal and emotional range while avoiding the pitfalls of over-saturation.
If you’re unsure about what song fits your voice and type, I can help. I specialize in tailored song suggestions and audition coaching to ensure you shine in the audition room.
1. “Right Hand Man” – Something Rotten!
- Why It’s Underrated: While Something Rotten! enjoyed a Broadway run, its songs are not overdone in auditions. This number combines humor, strong character work, and impressive vocal stamina.
- Ideal For: Female-presenting performers with strong comedic timing and the ability to belt.
- What It Shows: Your ability to balance comedy with powerhouse vocals while portraying a quirky, confident character.
2. “Pretty Funny” – Dogfight
- Why It’s Underrated: Dogfight is loved in musical theater circles, but this song is less common in auditions compared to “Before It’s Over.”
- Ideal For: Mezzo-sopranos with a rich, emotional tone who excel at quiet vulnerability.
- What It Shows: Emotional depth and control in quieter, introspective moments. It’s a great choice for performers who want to connect deeply with the material.
3. “Run Away with Me” – The Unauthorized Autobiography of Samantha Brown
- Why It’s Underrated: This song is stunning, yet it flies under the radar because the show isn’t as widely known.
- Ideal For: Tenors or baritones with a pop-leaning voice and a flair for storytelling.
- What It Shows: Dynamic vocal range and the ability to create an intimate, heartfelt moment.
4. “What If” – The Addams Family
- Why It’s Underrated: While The Addams Family is popular in regional and high school productions, this number from Wednesday Addams is less frequently performed in auditions.
- Ideal For: Mezzo-sopranos with a modern sound and a youthful edge.
- What It Shows: Your ability to balance teenage angst with vocal maturity. It’s perfect for contemporary roles requiring both energy and depth.
5. “Party Dress” – Henry and Mudge
- Why It’s Underrated: This playful song is from a lesser-known children’s musical, making it an unexpected choice for auditions.
- Ideal For: Sopranos with comedic timing and an ability to portray youthful, quirky characters.
- What It Shows: Your ability to fully commit to character work and engage with the audience. This song is a hidden gem for performers looking to stand out.
6. “I Could Be in Love with Someone Like You” – Jason Robert Brown’s Songs for a New World
- Why It’s Underrated: This cut song from The Last Five Years is rarely performed but carries Jason Robert Brown’s signature emotional and musical complexity.
- Ideal For: Tenors who can combine sincerity with a conversational tone.
- What It Shows: Your ability to navigate difficult rhythms and deliver emotionally driven storytelling.
7. “I’ll Be Here” – Ordinary Days
- Why It’s Underrated: While Ordinary Days is a cult favorite, this emotional ballad isn’t as overdone as “Calm” or “Don’t Wanna Be Here.”
- Ideal For: Sopranos and mezzos who excel in heartfelt, dramatic pieces.
- What It Shows: Your ability to convey raw emotion and subtle vulnerability while maintaining vocal control. It’s perfect for auditions where emotional connection is key.
8. “Fight the Dragons” – Big Fish
- Why It’s Underrated: Big Fish has some gorgeous songs that don’t often make it into the audition room, and this is one of them.
- Ideal For: Baritones or tenors with a flair for storytelling and a strong belt.
- What It Shows: Your ability to create a whimsical, engaging performance while hitting soaring high notes. It’s a fantastic choice for actors who want to highlight their charisma.
9. “Safer” – First Date
- Why It’s Underrated: This high-energy, introspective song is from a lesser-known contemporary musical, giving you an edge over more popular choices.
- Ideal For: Tenors or altos with a rock edge and a knack for delivering rapid lyrics.
- What It Shows: Vocal agility, emotional range, and the ability to command the stage with modern material.
10. “The Life I Never Led” – Sister Act
- Why It’s Underrated: While Sister Act is widely performed, this touching number is often overlooked in favor of flashier songs like “Raise Your Voice.”
- Ideal For: Mezzo-sopranos or sopranos with a powerful belt and a yearning, introspective quality.
- What It Shows: Your ability to build from vulnerability to strength in one song, showcasing an emotional arc that’s perfect for audition rooms.
How to Choose the Right Underrated Song
If one of these songs resonates with you, here’s how to decide if it’s the perfect fit for your next audition:
- Match Your Type
- Consider whether the character aligns with your age, voice type, and personality.
- Showcase Your Strengths
- Choose a song that highlights your best vocal quality, whether that’s belting, emotional phrasing, or comedic timing.
- Consider the Role You’re Auditioning For
- Pick a song that aligns with the style and tone of the show you’re auditioning for.
- Avoid Overused Choices
- While these songs are lesser-known, always ensure they’re not overdone in your specific audition circuit.
Why Underrated Songs Work
Choosing an underrated song gives you a competitive edge. Casting directors are often fatigued by hearing the same popular songs repeatedly. When you bring something fresh and unexpected to the table, it not only showcases your creativity but also helps you stand out from the crowd.
Need Help Selecting Your Perfect Audition Song?
If you’re feeling overwhelmed by options or unsure about what will make you shine, I can help. My services include personalized song suggestions tailored to your voice, type, and audition goals. Whether you’re preparing for a local audition or a Broadway call, I’ll ensure you’re equipped with the perfect piece to showcase your talent.
Ready to stand out with a song that’s truly you? Let’s work together to craft your best audition yet. Contact me today!
Photo by Florian Wehde on Unsplash
Leave a Reply